Are you REALLY Hungry? (Hunger vs. Appetite)

By Kimberly Taylor

When you want to eat, can you discern if the desire is coming from hunger or appetite?

It’s a common issue, especially in our culture of food abundance!

Eating Addiction v2
Many modern, processed foods make it hard to discern the difference between true hunger and appetite.

While having enough food to eat is a blessing, it requires a higher level of discernment in your eating habits.


Many cues exist that ”feed” our appetites, from the food establishments on the corner, to the food commercials on TV in the evening, or even seeing our favorite snack foods in the cabinet.

What is a person to do?

The first thing to do is discover if your desire to eat is coming from hunger or appetite.

Here is why you want to determine this before eating: Many of us have learned to interpret ANY bodily discomfort as hunger.

So if you often eat for reasons that have nothing to do with hunger, then your weight can suffer, which can lead to chronic sickness and disability over time.

Here are some guidelines to help you discern whether the desire to eat is coming from hunger or appetite.

True Hunger

For clarity, true hunger is defined as ”A feeling of discomfort in the stomach area caused by lack of food, coupled with the desire to eat.”

So in order, here is the checklist to help discern true hunger:

  1. Lack of food
  2. A feeling of discomfort in the stomach area
  3. A desire to eat

All 3 must be present for true hunger, in that order.

The next time you feel a desire to eat, ask yourself, “Is this REALLY hunger I am feeling or something else?”

If you haven’t eaten in an hour or more and lack of food is really the issue, then EAT.

However, if you just ate an adequate amount and you still crave more food, then it’s time to take a hard look at your habits and food choices.

Many modern processed foods impair your body’s natural hunger/fullness signals, which can lead to out-of-control cravings and overeating.

So it’s important to ensure that the majority of the foods you eat support a healthy body and brain.

These are foods as close as possible to the way God made them, such as vegetables, fruit, proteins – like fish, meat, beans, etc, healthy fats – avocado, seeds, nuts, and carbohydrates – wild or brown rice, sweet potatoes, quinoa.

If lack of food is not driving your desire to eat then accept that, while you want to eat, that desire is not coming from hunger.

Real Appetite

Appetite is defined as a ‘strong desire or liking for something.’

So a craving for a specific food drives appetite.

If you want to eat but would refuse an apple if someone offered it to you, then your desire to eat is likely coming from appetite.

When the desire to eat comes, be willing to explore what’s really going on inside of you:

1.Place your hands on your stomach and close your eyes. Is the feeling of discomfort coming from there? If it is, then eat healthy, filling foods rich in protein, fiber or healthy fats in the right amount for you.

We cover specific food recommendations and suggested meal plan in the ‘Healthy Weight Loss God’s Way’ course in the Take Back Your Temple program.

2. If the discomfort is coming from elsewhere, such as from a headache, muscle tension, or discomfort elsewhere in your body, then address the discomfort at the source, such as take a hot bath, massage the muscles, stretch, or do tension release exercises.

It’s amazing how much pain and discomfort in our body is simply a symptom of chronic muscle tension. So having regular check-ins with your body daily to relax and release tension is essential.

3. Ask the Lord in prayer for what is causing your feelings of discomfort at that moment.

When I ate a lot of inflammation-causing foods, I felt hungry all the time too!

When the desire to eat comes when you are not hungry, it helps to get up and move to a room farther away from the food or focus on another activity so you can get mental clarity for a few minutes.

These steps will feel weird and wrong at first, but that’s only because you’ve programmed your brain to believe that when the desire to eat comes, that is a command to go get something to eat.

It doesn’t. Desire is just a suggestion.

I repeat: Desire to do something does not translate into a command! You have the power to decline the suggestion and go in a different direction.

You can program your brain to think differently through renewing your mind (see Romans 12:2).

The Bible says that it takes faith and patience to inherit God’s promises (Hebrews 6:12).

Key components of faith in this area are to:

  • See your identity as a fit, healthy person – one who exercises self-control with her daily eating habits
  • Believe that change is possible according to God’s word.

Patience is walking out your new identity day-by-day through the power of the Holy Spirit.

Will it be a struggle? Yes.

But struggle is good.

After all, struggle is defined as ”to make forceful or violent efforts to get free of restraint or bondage.”

If your appetite has you in bondage, then any efforts you make to get free are good.

May the Lord bless you on this path to freedom!

Be Blessed with Success,

Kimberly Taylor

Author of the Take Back Your Temple program

P.S. Do you struggle with overeating sugar? If so, you are not alone!

Overcoming sugar addiction was a key factor on my journey to losing 85 pounds and dropping from a size 22 to a size 8.

In our 14-day Sugar Detox Challenge online course (inside the Take Back Your Temple program), you’ll get the same success strategies and support to gain peace in your eating habits and achieve lasting weight loss.

Click here to learn more about the Take Back Your Temple program.

“Prayer for Weight Loss”

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Kimberly Taylor

About the author

Kimberly Taylor has a heart to encourage others struggling with emotional eating and weight loss. Once 240 pounds and a size 22 herself, she can testify of God’s goodness and healing power to overcome. She lost 85 pounds and have kept it off for over 18 years. Through the Take Back Your Temple Christian Weight Loss program, her goal is to inspire Christian women to live fit, healthy, and empowered in Christ.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}